Insights
How to Know If Your Marketing Agency Is Working
Reports full of clicks and reach don't prove an agency is working. Seven checks you can run yourself, plus what a useful monthly report should show.
Your agency is working if you can see more qualified enquiries or sales, at a cost you can afford, and the numbers in their report match what your inbox and CRM show. If the report talks mostly about impressions, clicks and reach, ask what those turned into. You can check most of this yourself in an hour.
Most business owners don't have time to audit their marketing, so they judge it by the monthly report and a feeling. The report says things are improving; the feeling says the phone isn't ringing more. Both can be honest. The checks below help you find out which one is closer to the truth, without needing to be a marketer.
Agree What "Working" Means First
An agency can only be judged against a goal you both agreed on. Pick one business outcome, such as qualified enquiries, booked calls, quote requests or online sales, and one number to track it by. Then agree how it is counted: what counts as a qualified enquiry, where it is recorded, and who checks it. If you never agreed this, start there. It is the most common reason good agencies and good clients end up disappointed with each other.
Seven Checks You Can Run Yourself
- Compare reported leads with your inbox and CRM. Take last month's lead number from the report and count the real enquiries you received from marketing. A small gap is normal; a large one means tracking needs fixing.
- Check you own your accounts. Your Google Ads, Meta Business, Google Analytics and Tag Manager accounts should belong to your business, with the agency added as a user. If they leave, your data should stay.
- Look at what is counted as a conversion. In Google Ads and GA4, see which actions are marked as conversions. A page view or a button click is not an enquiry.
- Open the landing pages yourself. Click a few of your own ads on your phone. Does the page match the ad, load quickly and make it easy to get in touch?
- Compare spend with the plan. Check the actual spend per channel against what was agreed, in the ad platforms rather than in the report.
- Ask what was tested last month. A working account changes over time: new ads, new audiences, new landing pages, things paused. If nothing changed for months, ask why.
- Know who does what. You should know who manages your account day to day, who you speak to, and what is and isn't included in your fee.
What a Useful Monthly Report Includes
A good report is short and starts with outcomes, not activity. It should answer five questions:
- What happened to the goal: enquiries, sales or booked calls this month, compared with last month and the target.
- What each outcome cost: cost per enquiry or per sale, by channel.
- What changed: the main things the agency did, such as new campaigns, new ads or budget moves.
- What was learned: which tests worked, which didn't, and what that tells you about your buyers.
- What happens next: the two or three priorities for the coming month, and anything they need from you.
Clicks, reach and click-through rate are useful for diagnosing problems, but they belong lower in the report, as supporting detail. If the outcome numbers look wrong, our guide to why GA4 isn't counting your enquiries covers the usual causes.
Red Flags vs Normal Early Noise
New campaigns need time to settle, especially on small budgets, so the first weeks are rarely a fair test. Search campaigns often show useful signals sooner than social or SEO work, which tends to build more slowly. What matters early is direction and honesty, not instant results.
- Normal: results that vary week to week, a learning period after big changes, early tests that don't work.
- Red flag: reports that only show impressions and clicks, no access to your own ad accounts, lead numbers that don't match your inbox, the same ads running unchanged for months, or no clear answer when you ask what a lead costs.
How to Raise It With Your Agency
Go in with numbers rather than a feeling. Share your count of real enquiries next to their reported number, ask how conversions are set up, and ask what they would change if the budget were their own. A good agency will welcome the questions, because clearer goals make their work easier to prove. Our article on why ad campaigns underperform gives you a few more questions to ask.
When an Outside Second Opinion Helps
Sometimes you can't tell whether the problem is the agency, the tracking, the offer or the follow-up after the enquiry arrives. An independent look at the whole path, from ad to enquiry to sale, can separate the four. It works best as a fair review, not a hunt for someone to blame.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long should I give a new agency before judging results?
Judge the setup and the reporting in the first month: tracking, account access, clear goals. Judge the results over a few months, because campaigns need time to learn and you need enough enquiries to see a pattern. Agree review points at the start rather than deciding on a feeling.
What reports should a marketing agency send every month?
One clear report that starts with outcomes: enquiries or sales, cost per outcome, what changed, what was learned and what happens next. Supporting numbers such as clicks and reach can follow. A short call to go through it is often more useful than a long document.
Should I own my ad accounts and analytics?
Yes. Your ad accounts, analytics and tag manager should be in your business's name, with the agency given access. That way your data, history and audiences stay with you if you ever change agency.
What should I ask an agency before I sign?
Ask how they will measure success, who will work on your account, what reports you will get and how often, whether you will own the accounts, and what they need from you. Ask how they would check your tracking before spending more.
Should a B2B company hire an agency or an in-house marketer?
It depends on how much work there is and which skills you need. An agency gives you several specialists for one fee; an in-house marketer knows your business deeply. Many companies use both: one person in-house who owns the goals, and an agency for specialist work. See our digital marketing page for what an agency like ours covers.
Want a second opinion on what your marketing is producing? Our free Growth Diagnostic looks at your acquisition, tracking and the path from enquiry to sale, and ends with the three things we'd prioritise. For tracking and reporting, see strategy & analytics; to check whether your leads are priced right, see what a good B2B cost per lead is.